Bonus Episode: The Disaster That Never Happened

Welcome to New-clear Shadows: Fiction Under Investigation. Before anything else, a disclosure, made plainly and immediately. The disaster in this episode did not happen. No recycling yard burned. No storm carried contamination across Hong Kong. The incident under review tonight exists in exactly one place: a film. Cesium Fallout, released in twenty twenty-four, directed by Anthony Pun, and starring Andy Lau. This programme normally examines real accidents, with real consequences. Tonight, with the fiction labelled as fiction, we examine an imagined one, and we investigate it the way we would investigate any other. Who made the decisions? What did they know, and when? And what did the physics actually say? Morgan Miller: This podcast was brought to you by flooftags. Visit floof tags dot com for one of a kind laser engraved pet tags. Morgan Miller: Cesium Fallout was marketed as Hong Kong's first radiation disaster epic. That description brings us to the investigation's first finding, which concerns the film's poster. The poster shows a fireball rising over the Hong Kong skyline, the visual language of a weapon. A sealed medical source of cesium one thirty-seven cannot produce a fireball. It cannot produce a flash, a blast, or a mushroom cloud. Its danger is precisely the opposite of spectacular. It is invisible. It is silent. And it travels on hands, shoes, clothing, and dust. The first departure from reality in this case occurred before the opening credits, in the marketing. Morgan Miller: The file, then. In nineteen ninety-six, Hong Kong's Financial Secretary, Simon Fan, loosens the inspection regime for shipping containers arriving in the territory. The purpose is economic: fewer delays, faster trade. The result is a gap, and gaps of this kind do not remain empty for long. Smuggled dangerous goods begin moving through the Kwai Chung Container Terminals inside the space his signature created. One container, declared as scrap metal, carries a cargo the firefighters identify on sight: magnesium. When magnesium burns, it burns white, an intense flame, and the crews are warned to avoid it. That is the fire that kills the firefighters at Kwai Chung. Among them is Simon Fan's wife, May. Morgan Miller: The investigation record on the prologue is unambiguous. A regulatory shortcut was taken. The shortcut was exploited. Men died inside the consequences. Simon Fan resigns from public life. He retrains, over years, as a specialist in waste management and radiation. The film is explicit about his motive, and the investigation finds it credible. It is penance. Morgan Miller: Investigators reviewing this case will note that the initiating failure is not exotic. It is the most common signature in this programme's archive: a control that existed on paper, relaxed by a person who would not be standing next to it when it failed. The disaster, when it comes, arrives eleven years later. But its first cause is a signature in nineteen ninety-six. Morgan Miller: Two thousand and seven. A fire breaks out at the Hung Lik Recycling Yard, near Queen's Hill, in Fanling. Firefighters from Luen Wo Hui Fire Station respond to what presents as an ordinary industrial fire, a number one alarm, later raised to a number three. Recycling yards burn often, and they burn dirty: plastics, pressurised containers, chemicals of uncertain identity. The crews proceed accordingly. By the time radiation is detected at the scene, responders have already entered the affected area. Morgan Miller: The first radioactive material identified is radium two twenty-six, traced to illegally dumped fluorescent paint. Radium has a long history in this programme's files; it was once painted onto instrument dials by hand. The peak reading reported at the yard reaches eleven millisieverts per hour. To calibrate that figure: an hour spent in such a field delivers roughly what several years of ordinary background radiation would. It is a serious field. It is also a local one. Radiation of this kind weakens rapidly with distance, which is why the men at the yard are in danger, and the city, at this stage, is not. Morgan Miller: Then comes the finding that changes the character of the incident. Investigators identify cesium one thirty-seven, present in sealed radioactive medical devices, and described in the film, correctly, as chlorinated cesium one thirty-seven. In the trade, the material is cesium chloride: a salt. It is the same compound, in the same kind of source, that stands at the centre of the Goiânia accident, which this programme examined in detail earlier this season. The investigation will return to Goiânia. It is unavoidable. The film insists on it. Morgan Miller: The film proposes two routes by which the material may spread. Rain, it says, will dissolve the cesium and carry it outward. And the fire will evaporate it, a process the film prices at only six hundred degrees. The investigation grades these claims separately. Dissolution is sound: cesium chloride dissolves readily in water, and rain falling on a contaminated site is a genuine mechanism of spread. The evaporation figure does not survive examination. Six hundred degrees is the neighbourhood of the element, cesium metal. The material in the yard is not the metal. It is the salt, and the salt holds together until temperatures far beyond it. The film has graded its own source using the wrong substance's figures. Morgan Miller: It is also worth recording what the film does not claim. Several reviews of Cesium Fallout report that its cesium ignites on contact with water. The record does not support this. The material in the film that reacts dangerously with water is a separate stockpile of magnesium, stored at the same yard, and identified on screen as not a radiation source. The film kept its hazards in separate piles. Some of its reviewers did not. The investigation corrects the record in the film's favour. Morgan Miller: Hanging over all of this is the weather. Tropical Storm Murphy is approaching Hong Kong, a system close to nine hundred kilometres across. The authorities model serious pollution within fifteen kilometres of the yard. A countdown begins, measured first in hours, then in ninety minutes, then in thirty. The storm is the film's clock, and its threat is stated plainly: when the rain arrives, the contamination goes everywhere. Morgan Miller: The approaching storm was expected to increase the geographical extent of contamination. This assessment was reasonable. However, the storm would not increase the radioactive activity of the released material. It would only move it. Weather redistributes contamination. It cannot multiply it. The inventory in the yard is fixed: one medical source, of a class this programme has examined before. A storm can carry a hazard across a map. It cannot make the hazard larger than it is. This distinction appears to have been overlooked during the emergency planning process. Morgan Miller: A note on the human timeline, because the film compresses it, and compression of this kind is how audiences learn the wrong lesson. The film shows people near the yard becoming ill early: vomiting, collapse, fear moving faster than the storm. In the record of real exposures, radiation sickness keeps a schedule set by dose. At very high doses, nausea can begin within the hour. At the doses a bystander at a distance would receive, symptoms may take days to arrive, or may never arrive at all, and the danger is measured in risk carried forward, not in drama on the day. Beside the source itself, among the men working in the yard, the film's faster clock is not unreasonable. The investigation notes the compression and grades it accordingly: true at the fence line, borrowed everywhere else. Morgan Miller: Midway through the emergency, the film does something unusual for a production of its scale. It stops, and it cites its source. In a briefing, an official names the Goiânia incident, and observes that only ninety-three grams leaked. The figure is correct. Ninety-three grams of cesium chloride, in Goiânia in nineteen eighty-seven, produced the worst radiological accident in the Western Hemisphere. The film has done its reading. The investigation acknowledges this, because what the same scene does next requires it. Morgan Miller: The scene reports that, in Goiânia, over one hundred thousand people were casualties. The record from Brazil is as follows. A radiotherapy source was left behind in an abandoned clinic. It was taken, and it was broken open. Its contents, a powder that glowed blue in the dark, were passed from hand to hand through a neighbourhood, rubbed on skin, shown to children, admired. Approximately one hundred and twelve thousand people were examined. Two hundred and forty-nine were found to be contaminated. Four people died. Among them were Maria Gabriela Ferreira, and Leide das Neves, who was six years old. Examined is not the same word as casualties. One hundred and twelve thousand frightened people queuing to be checked is its own kind of harm, and this programme does not minimise it. But the finding stands: the film took the number of people examined and reported it as the number harmed, and the borrowed scale of that single word carries the rest of the film's arithmetic. For the full account of what happened in Goiânia, listeners may refer to this programme's episode, The Glitter That Killed. Morgan Miller: While the physics is being graded, the politics proceeds on its own track. Hong Kong's interim Chief Executive, Cecilia, is advised to withhold information from the public, in order to avoid panic. Across the table, arguing for disclosure, is Simon Fan: the man whose signature opened the door in nineteen ninety-six, now insisting that the public be told what is coming through it. Morgan Miller: The investigation notes that the suppression instinct is the most credible element in the entire case file. It is not a screenwriter's invention. It is documented behaviour, repeated across the real accidents in this programme's archive. Information is withheld for the same stated reason each time, public safety, and it produces the same result each time: a public that cannot protect itself, because it has not been told what to protect itself from, and that learns afterwards it was managed rather than informed. Morgan Miller: The projected figures grow as the storm approaches. Evacuation begins within five kilometres of the yard, then eight. The question of moving two million people is placed on the table. Here the finding is twofold. Evacuation is not automatically protection: moving two million people takes time the countdown does not offer, and routes run where the wind decides. In many radiological emergencies, sheltering indoors is the safer instruction. But a population cannot shelter intelligently from a hazard it has not been told exists. The failure in this file is not the choice of instruction. It is the hours spent choosing whether the public deserved one. Morgan Miller: The origin of the material, when it finally emerges, is not mysterious, and it is not an act of weather. A businessman, Peter Cowen, is found to have exploited customs procedures, importing hazardous material declared as electronic waste intended for re-export, and collecting disposal fees for material that was never properly disposed of. A network, including an official named Roger Fong, kept the route open. The investigation's conclusion on this point is short. The radioactive material did not arrive at the Hung Lik Recycling Yard by fate. It was brought there, at a profit, through decisions made by identifiable people. Morgan Miller: By the time the net closes around Peter Cowen, the yard has been burning for sixteen hours. Sixteen hours in which the fire service fought an industrial blaze whose true inventory had never been declared to them, inside a regulatory gap opened eleven years earlier by a signature, kept profitable since by men who sold disposal and delivered storage in a burning yard. The investigation draws the line plainly, because the film does: the fire was the trigger. The cause was paperwork, and the paperwork had names on it. Morgan Miller: The response converges, in the end, on engineering. The source is to be isolated behind one hundred and eighty centimetres of concrete, roughly six feet. The investigation finds the instinct sound: concrete shielding is standard practice, and the thickness genuinely required depends on the strength of the source and the geometry of the shielding. Six feet is generous rather than absurd. Around this core, the plan grows more desperate: demolition work near a water reservoir, racing the rain, with the odds of success stated on screen at fifty percent. Morgan Miller: And through all of it, the firefighters of Luen Wo Hui station remain at the yard as conditions deteriorate. The investigation records this without embellishment, because the real archive requires none. The people closest to a hazard of this kind are, reliably, the last to be told its nature. They stayed anyway. In the film, as in the record, that sentence describes the same people. Morgan Miller: The rain arrives. The operation succeeds, at cost. Twenty-four hours after the fire began, the emergency phase ends, and the institutional phase begins. Cecilia resigns, and cooperates with an anti-corruption investigation. Peter Cowen and Roger Fong are convicted and sentenced to thirty years. More than one thousand residents are recorded as contaminated. Some three hundred thousand people are resettled from the Northern District, and the affected area is described as uninhabitable for decades. Morgan Miller: These closing figures are findings of the film, not of physics, and the investigation grades them as such. A single source of this class, however badly mishandled, does not render a district uninhabitable for decades; Goiânia's contaminated ground was surveyed, cleared, and its waste removed, at enormous effort and expense. But the category of consequence is credible. Medical monitoring. Decontamination. Compensation. And a public that does not trust its officials on the subject of radiation for a generation. The film inflates the map. It does not invent the bill. Morgan Miller: The investigation therefore reaches its verdict in three parts. First: was the initiating accident plausible? Yes. An orphaned medical source entering the waste stream through illegal dumping, inside a system whose inspections had been loosened for profit, is not a screenwriter's fantasy. It is, almost exactly, the opening chapter of Goiânia, with the serial numbers filed off. Morgan Miller: Second: were the projected consequences justified? No. The film takes a neighbourhood-scale hazard, lethal to those standing beside it and ruinous to those who trusted its paperwork, and prices it as the end of a city of seven million. If I fail, millions die, says the film's hero, at his lowest moment. The record does not support the arithmetic. It supports something smaller, and in its way worse. Morgan Miller: Third: were the institutional failures credible? Yes, entirely. The loosened inspection. The fee collected for a disposal that never happened. The information withheld to avoid panic. The firefighters sent in ahead of the facts. Remove the storm, the countdown, and the skyline, and what remains is the most documentary material in the film. Morgan Miller: While the movie has taken many liberties with scientific facts, at least it didn't involve a gigantic lizard like Godzilla have. Morgan Miller: A closing note on the record. This investigation has graded the film's science throughout, and found the science wanting. It records no findings against the film's leading man. Andy Lau plays Simon Fan as a man serving a sentence he imposed on himself, and it is that performance, more than any fireball, that carries the case. Morgan Miller: This has been Morgan Miller, for New-clear Shadows. Fortunately, this particular disaster never occurred. The circumstances that could produce something similar require considerably less imagination. Morgan Miller: A big thank-you to floof tags dot com for sponsoring the show. Morgan Miller: If you are enjoying New-clear Shadows, please follow or subscribe wherever you are listening. It helps others find the show. Morgan Miller: Visit our website, nuclear shadows pod dot com, for more information.